MadSci Network: Botany |
It depends what kind of growing system you use. If you use a purchased potting soil, the beans will probably grow well at first but soon become deficient in mineral nutrients because potting soils are designed to require frequent fertilizer applications. In this experiment, a control treatment would be bean plants in potting soil receiving a fertilizer solution (such as Miracle-Gro or Peters) instead of distilled water. If you grow the beans in distilled water only with no solid medium (hydroponics) then the beans will soon become stunted and will probably die. Distilled water lacks any of the 14 mineral nutrients plants require. In this experiment, a control treatment would be hydroponic bean plants with their roots in a complete mineral nutrient solution. If you grew the bean plants outdoors in a fertile garden soil, the beans would grow very well with only distilled water. Rain water is often close to distilled water in purity in terms of the amounts of essential plant mineral nutrients it contains. Garden soils are also much more likely to contain nitrogen-fixing bacteria that form nodules on bean roots and provide the plant with much of its nitrogen. References Re: Which plants are best suited for hydroponics and why?> Re: what are the chemicals in soil? What is nitrogen, sulfur , and phosphorus? Re: are nutrients and minerals the same thing?
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Botany.